Here's what criticism I've compiled so far about this:
1. Having a ROBLOX theme to something is all fine and dandy, but the name is something you do not want to do this to. Its unoriginal and unattractive to users in my opinion. Despite the name being potentially clever in some cases - replacing a random word with ROBLOXia or ROBLOX is not that.
2. Call of Duty is an overused mirror for FPS games on ROBLOX. There have been plenty of terrific remakes of them, and thus the odds of making another remake and succeeding are lowered as the interest in a new remake for users is lowered.
2b. Ignoring the fact that there have been already successful remakes of the game, remaking a game that already is popular and has a large community is already a bad idea to begin with. You're trying to make a less of an already great thing. Why not make a great thing instead?
3. I like that you're trying to collaborate here on IN, but
YOU need to put more effort into an idea first. This thread was like a blank piece of spiral notebook paper with the title, and nothing else. You have no ideas listed, you have no progress, no visuals, nothing to offer. Just a single idea that isn't even appealing or original. Do you
really expect people to be interested in this?
3b. Once you put effort into it yourself, others will support you. We're not your personal engineers for ideas, and if you personally can't put your pen to paper and make these ideas come to life because you lack the ability to script, build, or creativity then its just not for you and you shouldn't be trying to make a collaborative effort that you can't start let alone finish.
Lastly I just want to say that making an account for this specifically shows that you only joined the website to leach our time and abilities for your own needs. There's a lot of nice people here willing to help others out, but we're no fools. We deal with many people like you coming here nearly every week. We're not going to trust you either until you show more identity of yourself as well, like telling us who you are on ROBLOX, other contact sources if we're interested, etc. All you've shown us here is that you have some organizational skills by adding criteria of things that need to be done - which is hardly organizing at all when there's nothing to sort.
